 |
|
Thul-Hijjah 20, 1329 1) All what you have mentioned regarding the
authenticity of the status hadith is indeed beyond any doubt. Al-Amidi has stumbled in a
way which has proven his distance from the science of hadith, and from traditionists. I
have bothered you with mentioning his views in clarifying what is already clear. This is
my mistake for which I invoke your forgiveness, since you are apt to forgive. 2) I have come to know that there are others besides
al-Amidi from among your arbitraters who claim that there is no proof that the status
hadith has a general application, and that it is restricted to its own context. They
support their view by the hadith's text itself, saying that the Prophet's statement is due
only to its time context, that is, when he left him in Medina during the Battle of Tabuk.
The Imam, peace be upon him, asked him: "Why do you leave me with women and
children?" His answer, peace be upon him and his progeny, was: "Aren't you
pleased that your status to me is similar to that of Aaron to Moses, except there will be
no Prophet after me?" as if he (pbuh) explained that his position to him is like that
of Aaron to Moses when the latter left him to represent him among his people when he left
for the Tur Mountain [Mount Sinai]. The gist of the Prophet's statement would be something
like: "You are to me, during this Battle of Tabuk, like Aaron to Moses who had to
depart to communicate with his Lord." 3) Your arbitraters may even say that this hadith is
not a binding proof, even if its implication is general, and a restricted hadith cannot be
applied in its general sense, and peace be with you. Sincerely, S
|
